RTU or PLC: Which is Right for You?


By David Greenfield , Director of Content, Automation World

Though programmable logic controllers (PLCs) have become dominant across industry, there are still many applications using remote terminal units (RTUs). Deciding which is right for your use is a discussion that still continues.

The question of when it’s most appropriate to use an RTU or a PLC has not faded with the continued rise of the PLC and the PAC (programmable automation controller). In fact, a member of the Automation & Control group on Facebook (the Facebook counterpart to Automation World’s LinkedIn group), recently asked this very question.

The most detailed response explained that: an RTU is a “microprocessor-controlled electronic device that interfaces objects in the physical world to a distributed control system or SCADA system by transmitting telemetry data to the system and/or altering the state of connected objects based on control messages received from the system”; and that a PLC is basically “a digital computer used for automation of electromechanical processes. Because the functions of RTUs and PLCs overlap, RTUs tend to be used more for wide geographic telemetry, while PLCs are best suited for local area control.”

 
Other members of the group claim that the communications abilities of current PLCs “more than equal RTUs and they’re considerably more flexible and versatile” — even in applications requiring wide geographic use.

 
Thus, the debate rages on.

 
One of the better — and simpler — explanations I have seen over the years comes from Tetragenics (a supplier of SCADA systems and smart remote units). Basically the explanation says: If you need a stand-alone controller with power for your application, a PLC is likely your best choice. But be aware that some level of programming skills will be required. If you need a device to control multiple processes, without direct intervention from a controller or master, an RTU can provide many of the advanced control functions needed, as it is basically a direct interface between the field sensors, actuators and a central control unit.

 
Like most answers either/or questions, the answer always seems to be “it depends.”

———————————————————-

 
🕶 AdPlugIT

Local or remote real-time operational data monitoring is the precursor of the 4th industrial revolution and IoT (Internet of Things). Having your own means operational efficiency. Timely and accurate business decision. The power of data when you need it, where you need it. Space and time constraints totally eliminated.

We offer our expertise and experience on SCADA, BMS, FDAS, FMS, HMI, Controls, Automation and Instrumentation System Integration. We can build you one.

Would love to see your business fly!

https://jcgregsolutions.wordpress.com/2016/07/31/over-and-above-scada-bms-fdas-hmi/

Jess C.Gregorio

InSpecIT Inc.

Unit 719/722 City & Land Mega Plaza Bldg.

ADB Ave. cor. Garnet Road, Ortigas Center

San Antonio, Pasig City, Philippines 1605

gregoriojess@yahoo.com

Follow JcGreg’s Magazines

https://flipboard.com/@JessGregorio?tab=magazines

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s